Refurbishment vs Refresh: Choosing the Right Scope

When planning property improvements, understanding the distinction between refurbishment and refresh is crucial for setting realistic budgets, timescales, and expectations. This guide explains the differences and helps you choose the right approach.

Defining the Terms

Let's start with clear definitions:

Refresh (Cosmetic Update)

A refresh involves cosmetic improvements without significant structural or system changes. Think of it as "making good" or "freshening up" a space.

Typical refresh works include:

• Redecorating (painting and wallpapering)
• Flooring replacement (like-for-like or similar)
• Minor repairs and making good
• Deep cleaning
• Updating fixtures and fittings
• Replacing worn or damaged items

Refurbishment (Comprehensive Upgrade)

Refurbishment involves more substantial works, potentially including layout changes, system upgrades, or significant improvements.

Typical refurbishment works include:

• Layout alterations (removing or adding walls)
• Kitchen or bathroom replacement
• Electrical or plumbing system upgrades
• Window or door replacement
• Heating system upgrades
• Structural repairs
• Full property renovation

Key Differences

Understanding these distinctions helps with planning:

Scope and Complexity

Refresh:

• Surface-level improvements
• Minimal disruption
• Usually single-trade or simple multi-trade
• Limited planning required

Refurbishment:

• Deeper, more comprehensive works
• Significant disruption likely
• Multiple trades coordinated
• Detailed planning essential

Budget Implications

Refresh:

• Lower cost per square metre
• More predictable budgets
• Fewer unknowns
• Typically £50-150 per m² for residential

Refurbishment:

• Higher cost per square metre
• Greater budget contingency needed
• More potential for unexpected costs
• Typically £150-500+ per m² depending on scope

Timescales

Refresh:

• Faster completion
• Days to weeks typically
• Less dependent on other trades
• Easier to schedule

Refurbishment:

• Longer duration
• Weeks to months typically
• Complex trade coordination
• More programme risk

Permissions and Regulations

Refresh:

• Usually no planning permission required
• Minimal building control involvement
• Fewer regulatory considerations

Refurbishment:

• May require planning permission
• Building control notification likely
• Party wall considerations possible
• More regulatory compliance needed

When to Choose a Refresh

A refresh is appropriate when:

Property Condition

• Structure and systems are sound
• No significant defects present
• Cosmetic wear and tear only
• Recent refurbishment needs updating

Budget Constraints

• Limited budget available
• Need maximum impact for minimum cost
• Want to avoid major expense
• Staged improvements planned

Timescale Requirements

• Quick turnaround needed
• Minimising void periods (rental properties)
• Occupied property with limited disruption tolerance
• Seasonal timing constraints

Purpose

• Preparing for sale (cosmetic appeal)
• Tenant turnover (landlord refurbishment)
• Freshening up dated decor
• Addressing wear and tear

When to Choose Refurbishment

Refurbishment is appropriate when:

Property Condition

• Systems need upgrading or replacement
• Layout doesn't suit requirements
• Significant defects present
• Property dated or poorly maintained

Long-Term Plans

• Long-term ownership intended
• Want to add value substantially
• Creating dream home
• Modernising for current standards

Functional Requirements

• Current layout doesn't work
• Additional space needed
• Accessibility improvements required
• Energy efficiency upgrades desired

Value Enhancement

• Property below market potential
• Targeting specific buyer/tenant market
• Competitive rental market
• Development opportunity

Hybrid Approaches

Many projects fall between refresh and refurbishment:

Targeted Refurbishment

Focus refurbishment on key areas (e.g., kitchen and bathrooms) while refreshing other spaces. This balances impact and cost.

Phased Approach

Start with refresh to make property usable, then plan refurbishment phases over time as budget allows.

Refresh Plus

A comprehensive refresh with selective upgrades (e.g., new flooring throughout, plus kitchen appliance replacement).

Making the Decision

Consider these factors:

Assess Current Condition

Conduct honest assessment:

• Are systems functioning adequately?
• Is the layout suitable?
• Are defects cosmetic or structural?
• What's the remaining lifespan of key elements?

Define Your Goals

Clarify objectives:

• What do you want to achieve?
• How long do you plan to own/occupy?
• What's your budget reality?
• What's your risk tolerance?

Evaluate Return on Investment

Consider:

• Will refurbishment add proportionate value?
• Is refresh sufficient for your needs?
• What's the opportunity cost?
• What's the market expectation?

Consult Professionals

Seek expert advice:

• Contractors can advise on condition
• Surveyors can identify hidden issues
• Designers can suggest optimal approaches
• Estate agents can advise on market expectations

Common Scenarios

Real-world examples:

Landlord Property Between Tenants

Likely choice: Refresh

Rationale: Quick turnaround, minimise void period, maintain rental standard without over-capitalising.

Typical scope: Full redecoration, carpet replacement, kitchen/bathroom deep clean, minor repairs.

Family Home for Long-Term Occupation

Likely choice: Refurbishment

Rationale: Long-term ownership justifies investment, opportunity to create ideal layout and specification.

Typical scope: Kitchen and bathroom replacement, layout modifications, system upgrades, high-quality finishes.

Property Purchase Below Market Value

Likely choice: Refurbishment

Rationale: Add value through comprehensive improvement, bring property to market standard or above.

Typical scope: Full refurbishment addressing all defects and dated elements.

Occupied Home Needing Update

Likely choice: Refresh or Phased Refurbishment

Rationale: Balance improvement with disruption, potentially phase works over time.

Typical scope: Start with refresh, plan refurbishment phases around occupancy.

Budgeting Considerations

Plan finances appropriately:

Refresh Budget

Allocate for:

• Materials (paint, flooring, fixtures)
• Labour
• Minor repairs
• Cleaning
• Contingency (10-15%)

Refurbishment Budget

Allocate for:

• Design and planning fees
• Materials and labour
• Building control fees
• Temporary accommodation if needed
• Contingency (15-25%)
• Professional fees

Managing Expectations

Be realistic:

Refresh Limitations

A refresh won't:

• Fix underlying problems
• Change layout or space
• Upgrade systems
• Address structural issues

Refurbishment Realities

Refurbishment involves:

• Significant disruption
• Potential for unexpected issues
• Complex coordination
• Longer timescales

Conclusion

Choosing between refurbishment and refresh depends on property condition, budget, timescale, and objectives. A refresh offers quick, cost-effective cosmetic improvement. Refurbishment provides comprehensive upgrade with greater impact but higher cost and complexity.

Assess your situation honestly, define clear goals, and seek professional advice to make the right choice for your circumstances.

---

Need advice on your property improvement project? Contact Mitchell Contracting to discuss your requirements.